Regarding A $40.00 Gift Card Purchase

On 12/10/12 I purchased a $40.00 gift card at your store #10672 in Beachwood, Ohio. I thought I lost it and so I purchased another one for $40.00. I have since found the first one and was wondering if I could get a credit on my charge for the gift card that I found since I now have another one as well. The register # was 002, the Transaction # was 9327 and the cashier was I purchase many things in your store and would appreciate your help. Thank you, Margery E. Calatrello